The Pros and Cons of Buying Board Games Online vs. In-Store

Quick Answer

Buying board games online offers convenience, better prices, and access to a wider selection, while in-store shopping lets you inspect components and get instant gratification. Choose online for deals and rare titles, but visit a local store when you value seeing the game in person or need it immediately.

When it's time to add a new board game to your collection, you have two main routes: clicking 'add to cart' from your couch or browsing the shelves at a local game store. Both have their strengths, and the best choice often depends on what you're looking for—price, speed, or the tactile experience of holding the box.

This comparison breaks down the trade-offs of each shopping method, so you can decide with confidence whether to buy board games online or head to a board game store. We'll also highlight specific games that are easier to find online, like those from Capstone Games, and when it might be worth seeking them out in person.

Convenience and Selection

Online shopping for board games wins on convenience. You can browse thousands of titles at any hour, compare prices across multiple retailers, and read reviews from other players before committing. This is especially useful for niche or hard-to-find games, such as limited print runs like Orléans: Big Box, which may not be stocked on local shelves.

In contrast, a physical board game store offers a curated selection that you can see and touch. You can examine box art, check the weight of the components, and even ask staff for recommendations. However, the inventory is limited by shelf space, so you might not find every game you're looking for.

• Use online retailers for games that are out of print or have limited availability.
• Visit local stores to discover new titles you might have overlooked online.

Price and Deals

Online board game shopping often means better prices. Without the overhead of a physical location, online retailers can offer discounts and run frequent sales. For example, The Royal Society of Archeology is listed at USD 30.00 with a comparison price of USD 59.99, a significant saving that's more likely to be found online.

In-store shopping, on the other hand, may not match these online deals, but you avoid shipping costs and can sometimes find clearance items. Plus, supporting a local business can have community benefits. The key is to compare prices before you buy—check online first, but don't ignore the potential for in-store promotions.

• Always check the comparison price to spot genuine discounts.
• Factor in shipping costs when comparing online prices to in-store.

Immediate Gratification vs. Wait Time

One of the biggest advantages of buying from a board game store is walking out with the game in hand. No waiting for shipping, no risk of damaged boxes in transit. If you're planning a game night tonight, a local store is your best bet.

Online purchases require patience, though many retailers offer fast shipping. The trade-off is that you might have to wait a few days, but you gain access to a wider range of products. For example, the 2-Player Games Bundle is a great option for a quick purchase online, but if you need it for a specific date, check shipping times.

• For last-minute gifts or game nights, head to a physical store.
• Plan ahead for online orders to avoid disappointment.

Inspecting Components and Quality

When you buy board games in-store, you can open the box (with permission) and inspect the components. This is valuable for games where component quality is crucial, like those with intricate pieces or cards. You can also check for any damage before purchasing.

Online, you rely on product descriptions and photos. While most games are well-manufactured, there's always a risk of receiving a damaged item. However, reputable online retailers have return policies, and you can often find detailed unboxing videos or reviews that give you a sense of the components. For example, Tea Garden is a game with beautiful artwork that you might want to see in person before buying.

• Ask to see a game's components in-store if you're unsure about quality.
• Read online reviews that mention component quality before buying.

Trade-Offs at a Glance

• Price: Online often offers lower prices and frequent discounts, but you may pay shipping. In-store prices are typically MSRP, but you might find local sales. Check online for deals, but factor in shipping costs.
• Selection: Online stores have a vast catalog, including rare and limited editions. Physical stores have a curated selection that you can see immediately. Go online for specific titles, in-store for discovery.
• Speed: In-store gives you the game instantly. Online requires waiting for shipping, which can be a few days or more. Choose in-store for last-minute needs.
• Experience: In-store allows you to see and feel the product, and get advice from staff. Online relies on reviews and descriptions. Visit a store if you value the tactile experience.

Games to Consider

• The Royal Society of Archeology: At the dawn of the 20th century, the United Kingdom, fueled by King George V's passion for archaeology, was swept up in a wave of exploration. You'll lead daring expeditions across the globe in search of the century's greatest discoveries. This themed game is easier to find online, where you can compare prices and take advantage of discounts like the USD 30.00 price against a USD 59.99 comparison price.
• Orléans: Big Box: Widely considered one of the best bag-building games of all-time, immerse yourself in this complete collection of Orléans! Due to the scope of this project, Orléans Big Box is a limited print run. Limited print runs mean this game may not be available in local stores, making online shopping your best bet to secure a copy.

Which Shopping Method Fits You?

Best for

• Online shopping is best for bargain hunters and those seeking rare or limited print games like Orléans: Big Box.
• In-store shopping is best for those who want instant gratification and prefer to inspect components before buying.

Not for

• Online shopping is not for those who need a game immediately or want to avoid shipping fees.
• In-store shopping is not for those looking for the widest selection or the lowest possible price.

Ultimately, the decision to buy board games online or in-store depends on your priorities. If you value convenience, price, and selection, online shopping is a strong choice. If you prefer the tactile experience and instant availability, a local board game store is your friend. Many gamers use a mix of both—shopping online for specific titles and visiting stores for spontaneous finds. Whichever you choose, happy gaming!