Pagan Playmats Compared: Hunter vs Fate of Roanoke
By Capstone Games - Evolving Gameplay | Published: 2026-10-30
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Pagan: The Hunter Playmat and the official Pagan: Fate of Roanoke Playmat. See which layout, size, and price fits your play style.
Quick answer
If you want the full two-sided experience with player aids for both roles, get the official Pagan: Fate of Roanoke Playmat. If you primarily play the Hunter and want a more portable, budget-friendly command center, the Pagan: The Hunter Playmat is the smarter pick.
Two playmats, two different jobs
The Pagan: Fate of Roanoke Playmat is the official all-in-one mat for both the Witch and the Witch Hunter. It gives you a complete play area for a full game, with player aids placed next to the corresponding locations.
The Hunter Playmat is a sleeker, portable option built specifically for the Hunter side. It streamlines setup and keeps your clues, evidence, suspects, and allies organized, but it doesn't cover the Witch side.
So the real question is whether you want a mat that serves both players at once or one that focuses on the Hunter's workflow.
What the official playmat covers
The official Fate of Roanoke Playmat includes dedicated zones for Clue and Evidence tokens, Suspects, Allies, Hunter Locations, Action Pawns, Influence, and your draw and discard piles on the Hunter side.
Because it's designed for both roles, it's a larger mat that works best when you have enough table space. It also includes helpful player aids printed right on the mat, so you spend less time checking the rulebook.
If you often play both sides or want a single mat for a full game, this is the more complete option.
Why the Hunter Playmat might be enough
The Hunter Playmat is described as a sleek, portable command center. It's crafted specifically for Pagan: Fate of Roanoke but focuses on the Hunter's side only.
Its thoughtfully organized zones guide your gameplay at a glance, which is great if you want a cleaner, more focused table presence. It's also lighter on the wallet, with a lower price point.
The trade-off is that it doesn't include the Witch side, so you'd need to manage that part of the game without a dedicated mat.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Full game coverage: The official Fate of Roanoke Playmat covers both the Witch and the Hunter, making it the better choice for a complete table setup.
- Portability and focus: The Hunter Playmat is more portable and streamlined, ideal if you want a dedicated Hunter-side command center.
- Price vs. features: The Hunter Playmat costs less, but you give up the Witch side and the full set of printed player aids. If you're on a budget, the Hunter Playmat is a solid entry; if you want the complete experience, save up for the official mat.
Product facts
- Pagan: Fate of Roanoke: Playmat: The official playmat for Pagan: Fate of Roanoke provides room for a complete play experience for both the Witch and the Witch Hunter, with helpful player aids next to the corresponding locations. You get a single mat that supports both roles, so you can set up the whole game without needing extra player boards.
Pagan: Fate of Roanoke: Playmat - Pagan: The Hunter Playmat: The Hunter Playmat is a sleek, portable command center designed specifically for Pagan: Fate of Roanoke, with thoughtfully organized zones that guide gameplay at a glance. It's a more focused and portable option that keeps the Hunter's leads organized, but it only covers the Hunter side.
Pagan: The Hunter Playmat
Which one fits you?
Best for
- Players who want a single mat for both roles and appreciate printed player aids
- Those who have enough table space for a larger, full-game mat
Not for
- Players who only play the Hunter side and prefer a more portable, budget-friendly option
- Those who want a mat that covers the Witch side as well
